Can You Shoot Someone Who Breaks Into Your House?

Terrifying things can happen when a person breaks into your home. You might even have a firearm stashed at the most convenient place to reach in case an intruder breaks into your home. But are you allowed to fire it if you think you need to or have no choice?

Only a few people know what they need to do in this situation and mainly act only based on instincts. Here, you will find out how the law applies to this situation so that you can make the right decision.

Is It Considered Self-Defense For Shooting An Intruder?

The law allows individuals to protect themselves under reasonable circumstances, such as home self defense. Self-defense, the act of defending oneself, is also an affirmative defense when you’re charged with a violent crime. Self-defense makes an excellent legal excuse for a specific action when facing charges of assault or murder. But they must prove that it is a reasonable response in a trial at a court of law.

In most jurisdictions, you can use self-defense to protect yourself from a violent crime charge; you must be able to meet the following conditions:

1. The defendant must not be the aggressor.
2. You must only use enough force to defend yourself (there should be no guns in a fistfight).
3. You must have a reasonable belief that an attack is about to occur.
4. You must have a reasonable belief that force is necessary.
5. You must retreat if you can.

Are You Allowed To Shoot An Intruder?

There are many situations where an intruder could get to your home, at what time, and with whatever intentions. And one thing is likely to happen if you shoot the intruder and wound them. So, the question is, can you be charged for hurting this person? And what charges will you face if you do? And you might also wonder if you have any legal protection. The answers lie in your location and your situation.

If you shoot an intruder, you are entitled to the ‘Castle Doctrine’ and the ‘Stand Your Ground’ doctrine. They both belong to the vast self-defense concept and might help you legally, which also depends on what state you reside in. For example, contact a lawyer specializing in similar criminal cases.

The question of whether it is also illegal to shoot an intruder has answers that can lead to multiple routes because self-defense has to be proven, and the mentioned doctrines will have to apply.

What Is The Castle Doctrine?

The concept of Castle Doctrine is from the English Common Law, which is a law system based on decisions and customs instead of written laws.

The Castle Doctrine refers to the home being the ‘castle’ of the homeowner, and they are entitled to defend their property without retreating or attempting to.

At the least, the Castle Doctrine applies to many states and is a common form of law. In most cases, shooting an intruder in your own house can be viewed as self-defense or as protection of another. But conditions apply to it as well:

• The person entered your home illegally or without consent.
• You did not display aggression at first.
• You have the right to be where you stand.
• You are not committing a crime.

Realize that there’s is a difference between being in your home and the property. While some states acknowledge the homeowner’s right to shoot the intruder, the same rights might not apply when the person is only within the property and not inside the structure.

If the intruder is caught on the way into your house, they would have to be threatening, and you feel that it’s necessary to use force to stop the person before you’re legally allowed to shoot them. These conditions must apply to justify the act of protecting yourself from abduction, forced intercourse, death, and other types of harm.

What Is The Stand Your Ground Law?

The law about standing your ground revokes the duty to retreat. This particular law states that in times of specific situations, the homeowners can use force to defend themselves without retreating from danger. These laws were designed to create a distinction between people who have no choice but to protect themselves and to remove the prosecution of those who rightfully defended themselves without attempting to retreat from the threat they’re experiencing.

Individuals who claimed self-defense under the Stand Your Ground Law in some states such as Florida were offered immunity. They cannot be prosecuted but must present evidence to prove self-defense. Under an affirmative defense, the defendant who claims self-defense must prove that they acted in self-defense or in defense of another to escape trial altogether.

Considerations on using lethal force associated with the Stand Your Ground Law differ from state to state. Some maintain the duty to retreat at the involvement of deadly force. Other states exclude the duty to retreat in every situation.

What Is Using Deadly Force To Protect Property?

The use of deadly force is for the protection of yourself and your family. But when it comes to protecting your property, the rules are different. For example, in some states like Ohio, you cannot use deadly force to defend against robbery or theft.

One example is that you can’t shoot a burglar who made his way to your yard to steal your vehicle, especially if that person doesn’t have a weapon on him. If the person is also not an immediate threat, that could injure or kill you or any of your family members.

It’s also different if someone uses a weapon to commit armed robbery. If you feel that your life is in danger, you’re allowed to use deadly force. Some might question if you have broken the duty to retreat concept requirements in such situations.

In the state of Ohio, you have to retreat before attempting self-defense in public. But the requirement changed when the Stand Your Ground Law was passed. You cannot use self-defense if:

• If you threatened the person first;
• If people are leaving your home;
• If you’re resisting arrest;
• You are the one about to commit a felony; and
• You are not at home and see someone trying to break into your home.

Law allows you to defend yourself and your family when someone breaks into your home. But it can be tricky to prove in court that you acted in self-defense, even with the new law placing the burden of proof on the state.

If you happen to shoot the intruder inside your home, report the shooting immediately after calling the police. You’d want to contact a criminal defense lawyer for assistance. If the police start to probe you with questions, tell them that you don’t want to make any statements or answer questions until your lawyer has arrived.

Is Deadly Force Necessary?

Once a case involving a weapon reaches the court, it is up to the jury to determine if the use of force is necessary or justified. Is it necessary to shoot the other party at all? In Texas, the jury has a process that involves three steps they will use for the case:

1. The jury must first review the state legislation that contains the use of deadly force. Then, they must find a just cause for you to use that severity of force to stop the thief, trespasser, attempted kidnapper, or murderer.
2. The jury must determine that you have a justifiable belief that using deadly force will immediately stop the person from escaping the scene, fleeing with your stolen property, or shielding yourself from what harm the individual might commit.
3. The jury members must all agree that when you utilize deadly force, you believe you have no other choice or ways to protect your property from being carried away or to protect yourself. You must convince them that using less force would have led to you gaining serious injuries or lead to your death instead.

Besides the jury, the law enforcement and judge will also decide the severity of your actions.

Law enforcement in Florida will follow the Florida Statutes Section 776.032, stating that a person with a justifiable reason to use deadly force is immune to prosecution. They will partially decide if you are justified in using force. You would not be arrested in the first place if you were justified.

If the law enforcement arrests you, your lawyer can appeal a Motion to Dismiss, depending on immunity. There will be a hearing, and the evidence will be presented in court and will make the independent decision to place you under exemption based on justifiable use of force.

In Conclusion

Using a weapon to stop an intruder could be the only means you have to protect yourself, a loved one, or your property. However, shooting an intruder can lead to two possible routes: being charged with a criminal offense or escaping charges altogether.

There are laws about the two that will also vary from state to state. So, if you’re keeping a gun for protection, you must first learn about the laws in your state and what challenges you could face if you shoot an intruder.

Worthview